
Contains spoilers
It's rare in my experience to find a truly character-driven children's story such as this. This story is entirely about the children (and the adults in their world from the kids' point of view), not a grand adventure, even the mystery is entirely character-centered. I love that the kids' exhibit all the insensitive honesty and ill-timed sweetness of real children.
The stories of Anna and Marnie don't shy from the harshness that can be life for young kids but do so in a way that doesn't feel like sympathy farming, but rather as honest struggles that must be faced. The book is remarkably light considering the heaviness of what the girls go through.
I think the ethos of the book is well summed up in the line "Being loved, oddly enough, is one of the things that helps us to grow up".
Contains spoilers
The main issue I have with this book is superficiality. The characters are pretty flat and the intrigues of the plot are not explored in enough detail to really be eventful. I also find it uncomfortable how little weight is given to the seemingly major plot point of the characters' involvement in the slave trade, focusing exclusively on the feelings of people far removed from the reality of it and reducing the whole to a mere stumbling block for why two people can't be together.
This is such a nostalgic book for me. The first time I read it was my dad's beaten-up paper-back and then later I found the audiobook as read by Chris Barrie. I love both versions.
For audiobook folks: Chris' impressions of his co-stars are so spot on! Even if you're not usually an audiobook fan, I do recommend you give this one a try.