so fucking good!!!

cute and fun but nothing too special

wow, this was crazy! especially those last 200 pages. i have so many feelings about this...i had a lot of fun while reading this but at the same time so much stuff annoyed me!
like, i loved the friendships, Ruhn, the cat that is not a cat and the setting of the book. but at the same time, i wasn't a fan of the romance for the majority of the book (i only got semi invested in like, page 700) and the overall plot didn't feel original, in fact, it felt like a mashup of TOG and ACOTAR which annoyed me.

still, i'm interested enough that i'll be picking up book 2!

mixed feelings but overall cute

this was so wholesome and funny and cute. i had so much fun reading it.

GO READ THIS BOOK FOR CLEAR SKIN.

i don't understand the hype about this

clan war. fighting with magic jade. wow. that was great

this was funny and cute and i really enjoyed reading this

wow....this was fucked up...and i loved every second of it.

not every second though.

i mean why, just WHY, every penelope douglas book i've read has the same epilogue with BABY????? i'm kinda tired of that.

still gonna give this 5 stars though (a first for me in her books). what a ride

didn't like the writing style but loved the cozy vibes

cute, funny and amazing at the same time. i fucking loved this!!!!

buddy read this with my friend brooke

this was fucked up

sometimes i like to torture myself it seems

this just became my favorite fantasy series of all time

i wish alex's mom could be the real president of the usa

i dont know why the hell i read this

4.5. SO GOOD

wtf was this, im angry

why every romance book has to end with a baby and marriage?

not the kind of romance i like