 Back in a Spell
| 4 | |
 The Hustler Next Door
| 3 | |
 Things We Never Got Over
| 3 | |
 Ship Wrecked
| 3 | |
 Two Wrongs Make a Right
| 3 | |
 Wild is the Witch
| 3 | |
 The Undertaking of Hart and Mercy
| 5 | |
 Scandalized
| 4 | |
 A Psalm for the Wild-Built
| 4 | |
 The Bodyguard
| 3 | |
 The Hotel Nantucket
| 3 | |
 Just Another Love Song
| 3 | |
 Shipped
| 3 | |
 Forbidden Miles
| 2 | |
 Bombshell
| 3 | |
 Broken Miles
| 3 | |
 The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue
| 3 | |
 Spells for Forgetting
| 3 | |
 In the Event of Love
| 3 | |
 The Kiss Curse
| 4 | |
 June, Reimagined
| 3 | |
 A Kingdom of Flesh and Fire
| 3 | |
 Faking with Benefits
| 4 | |
 Bend Toward the Sun
| 4 | |
 The Sign for Home
| 4 | |
 Thank You for Listening
| 4 | |
 The Player Next Door
| 4 | |
 In the Middle of Hickory Lane
| 3 | |
 A Soul to Keep
| 4 | |
 A Forest of Stars
| 3 | |
 The Cheat Sheet
| 3 | |
 Second First Impressions
| 3 | |
 The Highland Fling
| 3 | |
 The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches
| 4 | |
 Love on the Brain
| 4 | |
 The Charm Offensive
| 3 | |
 The Last of the Moon Girls
| 3 | |
 Violet Made of Thorns
| 4 | |
 I'm Glad My Mom Died
| 5 | |
 Beauty and the Mustache
| 3 | |
 Happy Trail
| 3 | |
 Just Last Night
| 3 | |
 Delilah Green Doesn't Care
| 4 | |
 Astrid Parker Doesn't Fail
| 4 | |
 Huis van lucht en adem
| 4 | |
 A Curse of Blood & Stone
| 4 | |
 Below Zero
| 3 | |
 The Spanish Love Deception
| 3 | |
 Hook, Line, And Sinker
| 4 | |
 It Happened One Summer
| 4 | |
 Count Your Lucky Stars
| 2 | |
 Everything for You
| 4 | |
 Hang the Moon
| 3 | |
 A Lady for a Duke
| 4 | |
 The Soulmate Equation
| 3 | |
 My Favorite Half-Night Stand
| 4 | |
 Every Summer After
| 3 | |
 Stuck with You
| 3 | |
 Not the Witch You Wed
| 4 | |
 Nettle & Bone
| 4 | |
 Under One Roof
| 4 | |
 Something Wilder
| 2 | |
 One Night on the Island
| 4 | |
 Head Over Heels
| 4 | |
 The Astronaut and the Star
| 3 | |
 The Dating Plan
| 2 | |
 Written in the Stars
| 4 | |
 Kingdom of Ash
| 3 | |
 Book Lovers
| 5 | |
 Book of Night
| 4 | |
 Empire of Storms
| 5 | |
 Queen of Shadows
| 5 | |
 Heir of Fire
| 5 | |
 Crown of Midnight
| 4 | |
 Throne of Glass
| 4 | |
 A Sweet Mess
| 2 | |
 When We Believed in Mermaids
| 3 | |
 Reminders of Him
| 3 | |
 The Love Hypothesis
| 4 | |
 The Witch Collector
| 4 | |
 The Simple Wild
| 4 | |
 Witch Please
| 2 | |
 Firekeeper's Daughter
| 4 | |
 Running Wild
| 4 | |
 The Shadow of the Gods
| 4 | |
 All the Feels
| 3 | |
 Spoiler Alert
| 4 | |
 The Ex Hex
| 3 | |
 Totally Folked
| 2 | |
 The Paid Bridesmaid
| 2 | |
 The Flatshare
| 3 | |
 The Road Trip
| 3 | |
 Sin Eater
| 4 | |
 Fables & Other Lies
| 3 | |
 Payback's a Witch
| 4 | |
 From Bad to Cursed
| 4 | |
 Well Matched
| 3 | |
 Under the Whispering Door
| 4 | |
 Piranesi
| 4 | |
 The Lights of Sugarberry Cove
| 3 |
