 The Maniac
| 4.44 |
 What Waits in the Woods
| 4 |
 Midnight Is the Darkest Hour
| 3.71 |
 Annie Bot
| 3.95 |
 Search History
| 0 |
 Fearless Fearless
| 3 |
 Mrs. Caliban
| 3.54 |
 The Fellowship of Puzzlemakers
| 3.5 |
 The Butcher and the Wren
| 3.44 |
 Gallows Court
| 3.67 |
 Mortmain Hall
| 3.5 |
 The Puzzle of Blackstone Lodge
| 4 |
 The Changeling
| 3.81 |
 My Damage
| 5 |
 The Only One Left
| 3.9 |
 Out There Screaming:
| 3.4 |
 The Handyman Method: A Story of Terror
| 3.23 |
 Under the Influence
| 3.75 |
 The Trap
| 3.38 |
 Rabbit Hole
| 3.31 |
 Paradise
| 0 |
 Benny Rose, the Cannibal King
| 4 |
 Chlorine
| 3.62 |
 Upgrade
| 3.64 |
 Loop
| 3.46 |
 Cult Classic
| 3.38 |
 Sea of Tranquility
| 4.01 |
 The Only Survivors
| 3.48 |
 White Fuzz
| 3.5 |
 The Glass Hotel
| 3.83 |
 The Woodkin
| 0 |
 The Silent Patient
| 3.8 |
 Skeleton Crew
| 3.69 |
 Nemesis
| 2.86 |
 Everyman
| 3.57 |
 Horrorstör
| 3.57 |
 Goddamn Electric Nights
| 0 |
 The Hunger
| 3.63 |
 The Sun Down Motel
| 3.84 |
 Vera Wong's Unsolicited Advice for Murderers
| 4.03 |
 The Hollow Places
| 3.81 |
 Home Before Dark
| 3.9 |
 The 7 1/2 Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle
| 3.87 |
 Agents of Dreamland
| 3.43 |
 Mexican Gothic
| 3.75 |
 Goblin
| 3.7 |
 Dead Silence
| 3.76 |
 The Ballad of Black Tom
| 3.73 |
 The Nightmare Man
| 4.08 |
 A Slow Fire Burning
| 3.32 |
 The Brothers Crunk
| 3.5 |
 The Tower
| 5 |
 The Laughter
| 4.25 |
 Congo
| 3.34 |
 Joyland
| 3.88 |
 Bones & All
| 3.44 |
 Circe
| 4.25 |
 Survivor Song
| 3.51 |
 Her Body and Other Parties
| 3.78 |
 Delicious Monsters
| 4.3 |
 White Horse
| 3.4 |
 Stringers
| 4.67 |
 Knucklehead
| 3.5 |
 In a Dark, Dark Wood
| 3.36 |
 Just Like Home
| 3.49 |
 Bad Monkeys
| 3.63 |
 My Soul to Keep
| 4 |
 My Soul to Take
| 3 |
 The Living Blood
| 4 |
 Stardust
| 3.98 |
 The Southern Book Club's Guide to Slaying Vampires
| 3.79 |
 The Daddy Book
| 0 |
 The Vanishing Year
| 2 |
 Decipher
| 3.17 |
 Swan Song
| 4.13 |
 Prey
| 3.69 |
 The Finalists
| 2.83 |
 The Dead Zone
| 3.81 |
 Devolution
| 3.63 |
 Andromeda Klein
| 0 |
 Oryx and Crake
| 3.9 |
 The Talisman
| 3.81 |
 Sandkings
| 4.25 |
 The Fourth Monkey
| 3.85 |
 Heart-Shaped Box
| 3.59 |
 I’m Glad My Mom Died
| 4.48 |
 Bony-Legs
| 0 |
 After Dark
| 3.65 |
 Portnoy's Complaint
| 3.5 |
 Dark Matter
| 4.03 |
 Into the Light
| 3.5 |
 Star Wars: Hunters: Battle for the Arena
| 4 |
 Each of Us a Desert
| 3 |
 The Insiders
| 4 |
 You Only Live Once, David Bravo
| 4 |
 Magpie Murders
| 4.08 |
 Weaveworld
| 3.71 |
 Sho-time: The Inside Story of Shohei Ohtani and the Greatest Baseball Season Ever Played
| 4 |
 Post Office
| 3.73 |
 The Time Machine
| 3.69 |