J

I first read this book when I was a kid, and truly, it made me develop an irrational fear of zombies for the rest of my life. Talk about formative.

I realize, as an adult, that this book isn't very scary - and while I try to re-read it every few years to see if it still holds the #1 spot in my heart, it's been a little while since my last re-read. So, this is my review of reading this book as an 11 year old, from 20-some years in the future. (Maybe I'll re-read it again soon and then delete this review in shame, but I doubt it).

The thing that continues to stand out in my memory is the pacing. The pacing made me feel like I was running for my life and it seemed like there was no room to even breathe. The consequences of inaction waited at every turn, and the tension and the sense of impending doom were oppressive. I have never been able to exactly recapture this feeling since. I was and am a relatively slow reader, but this was one of those books that I managed to read in one day (next-day-me, who had to wake up early for school, was not super pleased).

The second big thing for me was that this was my gateway read into fantasy. The concept of the charter magic system, which includes both necromancy and - er, reverse necromancy? I know that just sounds like killing people - were so new to me. I couldn't believe how much the author had packed into one book - charter magic, multiple set pieces, traveling between two different countries/kingdoms. I know this is all pretty standard fare in the genre, but I didn't know that at the time. Plus, the added splash of horror was so incredibly welcome to a kid that couldn't get enough ghost stories. I kept having to peek out my window to make sure there wasn't a dead thing creeping up on me.

The last big thing for me was the cover. I know you aren't supposed to judge a book by its cover, but the original artwork by Leo and Diane Dillon, while less text accurate in what the main character looks like, was perfect and (for me) actually added more depth to the story. The solemn expression, the almost plain, almost austere design of the character - this was a new type of female character for me. I don't know how to exactly articulate this, but Sabriel was a girl who didn't know what she was doing but she was still...serious, competent, thoughtful, rational, heroic, smart, and surprisingly fearless despite being (rightly) terrified (and then grieving). I thought she was the coolest person ever.

So I guess it wasn't just the cover - it was the main character too. All of the characters were likable to me, but Sabriel is a character that I think I'll treasure for the rest of my life.

I think this book delivered exactly what I hoped it would - cute, easy to read, trope-y. It feels a bit like the book equivalent of...any kind of blue candy (jolly ranchers, lollypops, etc). It isn't the greatest gourmet food in the world, and it probably has a whole lot of sugar and chemicals, and you know that the blue isn't natural, but you still enjoy it in the moment and you know what to expect - no big surprises.

For folks that enjoyed this book, I would also recommend the Villains and Virtues series by A. K. Caggiano. Not the same story (obviously) but same root premise - sunshine character ends up hanging out with the grumpy villain for Reasons.

(I'm kind of loving this sudden popularity of making villains the main character - I love a morally gray character.)

A quote that stays with me (among so many - my book is highlighted to death - holding myself back from listing every beautiful quote is agonizing):

“Thank you for carrying me out of the dark,” he whispered.

tldr tldr (the shortest review): Reading this book felt like someone ripped out my heart, tenderly peeled it like an orange, and then lovingly fed the pieces back to me while looking deep into my eyes. Where’s my life alert necklace?

tldr (the medium length review): I have been trying to write a review for this book for the last two weeks, and I’ve scrapped every iteration because they just keep getting too long. There are just too many things to fit into a concise review that actually covers everything I want to cover. It feels a little like trying to talk to someone about an amazing dream or nightmare that you’ve had - it’s super interesting to you, but how can I articulately convey, like an adult, that this book gave me big feelings? It's tender, it's hopeful, it's devastating, it's romantic, it's dark, it's lovely. I know other reviewers mention that the beginning might feel slow - I just want to reiterate that this is a book that's really worth reading to the end to experience the complete emotional journey. If you reach the last page and think “eh” you can skip the sequel, yeah?

Now, the much longer (but still shorter than my first attempts) messy bullet points, spoiler tagged just in case (I've read the book twice now and am not sure which of these might be too specific? Spoilery? There's no real story spoilers in here, I think - just erring on the side of caution):

• If you like flawed main characters that aren’t immediately likable but become dear to you by the end of the book, there’s a character for you in this book. Bonus points if you like characters whose hardened exterior isn’t armor made of metal or chitin or scales, but layers and layers of that person’s own callouses and scar tissue.
• If you like respectful, kind, thoughtful characters that also have a a scary protective or ruthless layer, there is a Character in this Book for You.
• If you like the idea of a really…fresh new world that seems to straddle the line between fantasy, scifi, horror, and a little bit of…steampunk? Almost? you should read this book. The world building is great and the magic system feels NEW, but also - it doesn’t feel SO foreign that you find yourself floundering through the whole book wondering what the hell is going on. The settings, the magic, the world - it feels very rich.
• If you like beautiful writing that isn’t so beautiful and dense that it becomes impossible to read, this is it! This is the one! Read it!!
• If you aren’t into love triangles/squares/polygons-of-some-shape, and live more by the “por que no los dos” ethos - congratulations! I know who the “main” pairing of this book is, but honestly - everyone seems kind of into each other in a whole variety of ways (physically! emotionally! romantically! queer platonic! ambiguously tenderly!)
• If you have mixed feelings about love at first sight, can I offer you: Desperate, breathless relief at first sight?
• Mirrored dialogue at different points of the story - ugh, so good.
• If you like slow burn romance, you’ll probably like this book.
• If you squint, there’s a bit of a grumpy/sunshine dynamic here, but with more ~*~nuance~*~
• You know those couples that finish each other’s sentences and just seem to exist in a perfectly symbiotic relationship that goes beyond physical attraction or romance? I’m not saying we get all the way there quite yet, but it turns out sharing a body is like the ultimate bonding experience.
• If you love complicated and deep friendships, you’ll probably like this book.
• If you love relationships where characters grow to know and need each other (to the point where everyone’s fighting to die for each other like my extended family fighting over a dinner receipt), you’ll love this book.
• No, seriously. It’s so…tender. Reading this book left me with this…ache. Finishing this book, even the second time, knowing everything,left me feeling like I’d been running uphill for five minutes.
• If you like hyper competent, nerdy academics with hearts of gold (UNLESS SCIENCE - but even then!), there’s a character in this book that you’ll love. Also pigeons.
• If you like broad shouldered red headed ladies that could break you in half and scowl a whole lot, there’s a character in this book that you’ll love.
• If you like hardened crime lords with a soft spot for the main character, there’s a character in this book that you’ll love.
• If you like scary monsters, there are several described and interacted with in this book!
• Er, and if you like like scary monsters, I mean - there’s at least one super scary monster nightmare that croons and is weirdly…tender, while still being totally alien and terrifying.
• If you loved that ottoman dog from Beauty and the Beast - look, just read the book. This book has everything. It’s incredible. I can’t compliment it enough.
• Oh, bonus!: If you like characters that are queer but it isn’t a defining trait or the basis for an Extremely Angsty Subplot and Death, you’ll love this book too!

Comparisons to other stories (books/movies):

• If you loved Sabriel by Garth Nix, this book - well, it’s not the same, but it explores some of the same themes - death, grief, loss, hope, love, friendship, family. Even though it’s different, it just shares a vibe, you know?
• If you loved Mako and Raleigh’s dynamic in Pacific Rim but felt like Mako could have bullied Raleigh a little more, you might like Asunder. I think the main characters are pretty clearly drift compatible.
• Did you love Jokaste from Captive Prince, but were like “I wish she was using her powers for good”? There’s a character you should meet in Asunder!
• If you loved Harrow from Gideon the Ninth, you’ll probably love the shit out of Karys. Prickly.

This novella was one I was really looking forward to, based on the premise - but it wasn't what I expected, and I found myself a little disappointed by that towards the middle...but I feel like the whole thing wrapped up in a way that left me feeling good about it again. It won't be my favorite read of the year, but I would easily recommend it to someone else - just don't expect a super spooky, unsolved mysteries style scary story. :) Be pleasantly surprised.

I enjoyed this novella - it was the right length for the story being told. The author's pacing was great for me.

I struggled a bit with Ada's "voice" - I found her to be a little too...manic pixie dream girl who is also a criminal? I don't know if that was meant to be intentional - she's a fake in every way, etc - but it felt forced and not as charming and witty as I think the story wanted her to be, though I could be wrong. I couldn't figure out if she was meant to be an unlikable protagonist on purpose, I guess. I could be reading too much into it, but I feel like that might have actually been the case - she felt more sincere and genuine (and likable) at the end of the story, despite her revealing herself to be a liar and a very manipulative person. That's what I would like to believe, in any case.

I think I enjoyed the epistolary style section at the end of the book more than the first person narrative that made up most of the book, but that might just be my own bias (I love stories that utilize letters, or excerpts from "articles" or "books" from the universe.)

Since it's such a fast read, I would feel comfortable recommending this book to most people with similar tastes. I'm looking forward to reading the next entry in the series, since Ada's betrayal is out of the way and she won't need to be playing whatever character she was playing in the first book.