
Great book with great info. Super repetitive however, and not necessarily in the way you'd think but it's like the book is constantly marketing itself. Instead of an overview of the book in the first chapter, it's like the book is giving overviews throughout the book. “As you'll see in chapter X” is repeated about a million times (more or less).
5 stars for material, with a 2 star deduction for wasting my time with useless repetition.
This book was way better than I expected. Unlike previous works like Remote which I found rather repetitive at times, this book was packed with goodies and common sense tips for how a business should be run. Frankly I regret never having applied to 37signals after having read this book. I was an early adapter of Ruby to boot (I wrote my first pages in 2002, 3 years before the first version of rails).
I like the test at the end but I think the overall strategy is more difficult to read than tsumego type problems (of which there are an abundance) so the more valuable tests would have been more battle strategies. All in all, I feel the battle strategies chamber should be longer since its the hardest to find resources on. Furthermore, it's also the title of the book.
At times I thought the conclusions reached were not so scientific that Mo had liked. He's very particular about the science behind things, but I ended up feeling there were gaps in reasoning.
At other times I found the story to be moving and compelling. Finally I don't see the science necessarily being as necessary as the peacefulness one can achieve in the pursuit of happiness.
I found the epilogue to be especially touching. All in all, it was a great story.
Neil Gaiman knows how to spin a tale and he's skilled at storytelling. Unfortunately, the main plot is weak, and many of the plots don't really seem to lead anywhere. With a big book like this, it's a big undertaking and takes a lot of time to go through it, and at the end you hope to get more out of it.
This book was really stupid. I kept reading it because I could not not read a book which has a Commodore 64 in it and lots of other neat stuff. While that did make up for many things, it didn't nearly make up enough. The book had a very terrible plot line, the “bad guy” was far too obvious and uninspired. There was little character development to speak of, in fact, most characters were rather shallow. If you want to read it, count on reading almost all of the book before there's any revelation as to what the main plot is. Sadly. Some parts were funny, others silly, and some downright stupid. So much for trusting all the good reviews.
There are two reasons I didn't think this book deserved a five star which isn't surprising many people give it. My reasons are pretty basic too.
1. There's simply a lot of fluff. The added stories are relevant and add to his point, but there's still a lot of fluff around what he's trying to get across.
2. it really annoyed me when he talked about Lincoln as he cared about slaves. There were several other passages about famous people (or notorious as Lincoln is more aptly described) that I also didn't agree with. Lincoln was one of the most hated presidents ever during his time.
“I will say then that I am not, nor ever have been in favor of bringing about in anyway the social and political equality of the white and black races - that I am not nor ever have been in favor of making voters or jurors of negroes, nor of qualifying them to hold office, nor to intermarry with white people; and I will say in addition to this that there is a physical difference between the white and black races which I believed will forever forbid the two races living together on terms of social and political equality.”
- Lincoln during his fourth debate with Stephan Douglas - Sept. 18, 1858
That said, the actual material itself and the lessons are worth five stars.