Easy and enjoyable read. Perfect for a summer read.

I found the story rather drawn out as it was more narrative than I generally read. It may not be fair to judge a book that way, but I am. I found myself not drawn to keep readin, even when I reached the “exciting” parts. In many ways I was more relieved when the end was reached.

I read this book, and processed it as an adult. Therefore I really did not think that Harriet's behavior was appropriate for children to see. In many ways she is a spoiled, obnoxious brat. And in many ways deserved what she for when her classmates read her notebook.

I found the story rather boring, and confusing as it kept switching from character to character and present to past and back to present.

I found myself finally starting to enjoyed the story and then it ended.

I enjoyed the story. I wish I could go to Fontinari's and meet Sal and the rest of the characters.

I'm not sure I liked the ending. It felt rather anti-climatic Billie meeting Lulu so quickly and easily. And Lulu not wanting to share her side with Billie.

The book follows a basic formula. It was enjoyable to read. Mrs. Merkle was a great character.

Honestly, I would rather rate the book as a 2.5, but decided to round up instead. The end of the story was quite interesting, the whodunit was a surprise. I'm just not sure I could make the same decision Jake did. Almost gave up on the book as Jake's actions actually made me mad.

I found the story very interesting. The writing style reminded me of Charles Dickens. Which shouldn't surprise me as he is a co-star. My only negative about the book is wishing to know what happened to Mr. Bogel, aka Bogus Bogel.

I have to say this was the darkest of the 3 in the series. And that I personally would not share this with my daughter who is 7. My son, who is 13, would probably be ok with the darker tones but would not enjoy the book.

A delightfully engaging story. It time flips from 2009 back to 1839-1845. It was a refreshing change from some of the more recent books I've read recently. I enjoyed the journey as Julia unraveled a centuries old family secret.