Robin Madeiros

I enjoy all Seanan McGuire books. This one was just as good too. Very is a bit more snarky but I still like her. I really can't wait to start the next book.

I liked this book. It brought up a bunch of good questions on using and abusing children and their trust, bringing a war to where there is none presently, communication with the enemy, and so much more.

The ending of the book did not satisfy me. There were a lot of loose ends that I wished were tied up. Some questions were answered at the end. But still way too many questions left unanswered.

It was a good book. Not bad for YA fiction. I'm interested to see what happens in the movie.

I liked this book. Almost as good as the original books. It took me right back into the world, even though the characters are different.

Glad I finally read this one. Interesting story. I wish I was as self aware at her age as she was.

I liked it. Of course I'm not a good mystery reader, so I didn't see it coming. I liked the premise.

I really liked this book. The story was interesting and so were the characters. The way it was written, weaving both the old and the new stories in a detective type story was fun to read.

Interesting twist to the ending. I may want to read the other books in the series. I'm assuming it's a series, it can't end the way it did.

Another good book. The stories weave around each other so well. I can't wait to read the next one.

Interesting book. I don't see what it had to do with the Birth of Venus painting, but the story was interesting.

It was a really interesting point of view and did not follow as I had expected.

I didn't think this book was going to end. Just when you thought there was one ending, the story was still going. I really liked it though.

I liked the book overall. Some of the situation seemed contrived.

I liked this book. If I weren't reading so many others right now I'd start the next one.

Good quick re-read. I'm excited to continue the series now.

This was a really good story. I listened to it and the reader did a wonderful job.

It was a good book. There were some lose ends that needed tying together. The mystery was not explained too well at the end.

Really good, I like the October Daye series. Thank You Seanan McGuire.

I liked it. It was as good as Pride and Prejudice and Zombies. The addition of Sea monsters was woven into the book flawlessly.

I liked this book. The characters were interesting and the story was was too.

I liked this and will continue on with the series. It's an interesting premise, if it doesn't get too repetitive. There are so many possibilities.

Pretty good. I didn't see the ending coming. But I'm glad it worked out the way it did.

I thought I had read the book before, and once I started it, it was familiar. But I couldn't put it down. So I finished it. I'll probably look for the other two in this series in the used bookstore. I'll read them again too if I can find them.

Third time reading because I'm doing all the books this time around. It's still as good as I remember.