This volume was unfortunately too boring and stagnant. Also, I don't see where all the story will be going.

3.5 stars.

As far as I enjoy the humour and what happens to our character, there's no plot progression nor character development and I start asking myself if there's going to be any.

Unpopular opinion here xD

I found it was nice to move away a bit from the school and to focus on Your, but still there's little story progression and world building.

3.5 Stars.

Grafica: 5 stars
Story/plot: 2 stars, mostly absent.
Characters: 4 stars. Very good introductory characterization.

Speravo che il manga mi potesse aiutare di più a capire chi è chi, ma non è servito a molto.
Grafica carina. La storia per sé è interessante ma non mi ha preso molto.

2.75/5

It's the 28th February. HOSAB came out a couple of weeks ago and 141 people already rated the book 4 or 5 stars. That's annoying.

3.75 stars.

Novellas do not really work for me and this one made no exception. However, I liked the characters and story very much.

2021: Rated down to 3 stars. I could not connect to the characters and did not enjoy the Western atmosphere.

3.5 stars.
Well written book with a very interesting story. However, characters were pretty flat.

3.75 stars.

Finally the series got closer to the lords of deliverance: more focused on plot and characterization. I liked Ideas and Lore very much.
Only con: being a Paranormal romance with quite of sex thrown out all over the place.