okay i think this book is good at being what it???s supposed to be, which is a kind of parody of romantasy & bodice rippers!! a lot of issues i???d normally take with a book (certain cliches, the comically naive fmc, the ridiculousness of some of the sex scenes) kind of get a pass because it???s clearly genre aware and poking fun at the conventions. that said i do wish we got more of gwen???s feelings about her family sorted out on page, the ending felt a bit rushed and some of the dirty talk was just. comically bad. also i fear the male audiobook narrator???s voice did not suit oskar at all. overall certainly not a masterpiece but i had a fun time.
this book is so smart. everything is meticulously laid out and layered while still being effortlessly funny and entertaining. this is actually my second read, but amnesia snatched most of the details away from me the first time, so it???s been a treat to go back and rediscover the intricacies of the mystery. i love the casual queerness and the interaction of the world???s religion with magic and sci-fi elements. the worldbuilding is constructed in such a way that you get a good sense of each of the houses without ever actually seeing them on-page, which is impressive given the scope of the setting. harrow and gideon???s arcs and the evolution of their relationship was extremely satisfying, and i can???t wait to see how things pan out in the next book!