Batman Villains: Secret Files & Origins 2005

Only read this for the Mignola story If a Man Be Clay which is a near panel-to-panel remake of an original Detective Comics issue. The dialogue is cheesy, the scenarios are strange, and it's all perfectly told through Mignola's art. I liked the fact that this was a self proclaimed pre-crisis story, something I don't think we get enough of.

The expressionist flair of the art really gave a new tone to this story, especially reading it back to back the original issue. I know he really doesn't like Batman that much but I could easily read a whole book of Mignola retelling Golden Age Detective Comics.