Deck the hounds
Ratings3
Average rating3.7
15
Ratings3
Average rating3.7
"Reluctant lawyer Andy Carpenter doesn't usually stop to help others, but seeing a dog next to a homeless man inspires him to give the pair some money to help. It's just Andy's luck that things don't end there. Soon after Andy's encounter with them, man and dog are attacked in the middle of the night on the street. The dog defends its new owner, and the erstwhile attacker is bitten but escapes. But the dog is quarantined and the man, Don Carrigan, is heartbroken. Andy's wife Laurie can't resist helping the duo after learning Andy has met them before... it's the Christmas season after all. In a matter of days Don and his dog Zoey are living above Andy's garage and become two new additions to the family. It's not until Andy accidentally gives away his guest's name during an interview that things go awry; turns out Don is wanted for a murder that happened two years ago. Don not only claims he's innocent, but that he had no idea that he was wanted for a crime he has no knowledge of in the first place. It's up to Andy to exonerate his new friend, if he doesn't get pulled into the quagmire first. David Rosenfelt's signature wit, charm, and cleverness are back again in this most exciting installment yet" --
Reviews with the most likes.
This originally appeared at The Irresponsible Reader.
—
Andy Carpenter sees a homeless man with a dog on the street, gives the man some money and a gift card for dog food (naturally, the dog gets more than the man, because it's Andy Carpenter) and has a brief conversation with him. Not long after that, that same man is on the news – he'd been attacked by a stranger and his dog defended him. Which resulted in the dog being put in the pound. Laurie's filled with pre-Christmas spirit and insists that Andy help out. So he uses his rescue foundation to get custody of the dog and moves the pair into the apartment over his garage.
How heartwarming is this? Clearly, this is fodder for a Christmas/holiday story. But it's also an Andy Carpenter story, so naturally, after Andy does a newspaper interview about the man – giving his name – he's arrested for murder. No one was more surprised by this move than Andy's guest, Don. Not only has Don never heard of the victim, he was unaware that he was wanted by the police. Laurie's pre-Christmas spirit is still strong, so she talks him into defending the man. It helps that he's innocent, a dog lover, and an educated, articulate vet with PTSD. The PTSD aspect of the story was told with sensitivity and tact. It didn't feel tacked on to make the character more sympathetic, but it grounded him in reality and may help to inform some readers about the prices that too many vets are paying.
There is another storyline – seemingly unrelated – running through the novel. Obviously, it's going to tie into Andy's case, but it takes a long time for that to happen. This gives the reader multiple opportunities to guess how the two are connected (and multiple opportunities to be wrong. I guessed what was happening in that story pretty easily, and I think most people who read a lot of legal thrillers will. But how it connects to the main story will likely leave most readers as surprised as I was (surprised, and then filled with a strong sense of, “well, naturally, what else could it be?”).
The usual gang is back and in their prime form – Hike is back to his full-time dour self; Ricky is a cute kid; Laurie provides the moral center; Pete is a good cop who continually underestimates Andy's clients; Sam is a wizard with computers in a way that probably defies reality Marcus is his super-hero best here, and possibly faces his biggest challenge yet (I thoroughly enjoyed this scene). What better way to spend a holiday (or at least a book set around one) than with a bunch of friends like these have become over the years?
Andy spent more time in the courtroom in this book than he has lately – it seemed to me, anyway, I didn't do a page count. His courtroom antics and cross-examinations are what drew me to the character in the first place, so this is the stuff in these books I most look forward to. Rosenfelt brought his A-game to the courtroom events here, and I loved it. As far as mysteries go, this in one of the most satisfying cases that Rosenfelt has brought us in years.
In my post about the previous “holiday special” I said that I really don't like it when long-running series do a holiday special – yet, The Twelve Dogs of Christmas and Deck the Hounds have been my favorite installments in the last couple of years in this series. Maybe that means this Grinch's heart is growing a couple of sizes, or maybe it's that Rosenfelt is inspired to work harder in these. My guess? It's the clients – the Andy Carpenter books are at their best when they focus on the client, not on some large conspiracy. These holiday books have the kind of clients you spend time on, that the reader gets invested in – and therefore, Andy gets to shine in defending them.
Whatever the reason, this is a sure-fire win for Andy Carpenter fans. Particularly if you don't mind a little Christmas celebration (or, if you're like Laurie, and insist on commemorating the holiday for months).
Disclaimer: I received this eARC from St. Martin's Press via NetGalley in exchange for this post – thanks to both for this.
