Ratings1
Average rating5
Reviews with the most likes.
There's some staggering and beautiful detail hidden in the undergrowth of this book, particularly in the earlier parts, and many new previously unknown texts it revealed, but a couple of things throw it off. Keeping in mind it's written in the early 90s, and that its stated mission is the place of forests in “western” thought, I can almost forgive its overwhelming whiteness and eurocentricity, thought it is a missed opportunity – I wanted to read the version of this book that really wrestled with, or at least nodded to, how humanity as a whole considered the forest as shadow space. Even when it arrives in the Americas at the end, really there's only Thoreau and Frank Lloyd Wright. Secondly, was there not a single damn woman over all these millennia surveyed that had a thought worth noting about forests? Not a one? I can't forgive that for its time of writing. It also degenerates into its second half to a succession of middling lit crit essays about things (poems, paintings, buildings) with trees in them, which is not really what the promising core thesis was about. Alas.