Sea This and Sea That

★ ★ ★ 1/2 (rounded up)
This originally appeared at The Irresponsible Reader.
—
Off the top of my head, there are essentially three types of Picture Books:
1. ABCs/123s
2. Stories told simply (usually with pictures helping the text tell that story)
3. Odd little collections of interesting/goofy pictures with some text to tie them together.

Myself, I prefer the stories—I'm always on the side of a narrative. But from my observation of my kids, niece, and other children, the third seems to be the most popular. They don't need a grown-up around to “read” the book on their own, they can just pick it up and flip through the pictures, and the text (usually rhyming) sounds entertaining enough, even if they don't really get what's being said. I really know that's true for my kids, they'd request demand them far more frequently—I can still probably rattle off Boynton's But Not the Hippopotamus with only a prompt or two, despite not having picked up the book for 12-13 years.

It's also the kind of book that Billups provides here—it's set in a “crowded, hectic and gruff” city under the sea, with one quiet spot—The Sea This and Sea That Below the Seashore. Missus Bluffington gives a couple of kids (and the reader) a through her very unusual place, full of all sorts of sea creatures, sea plants, fish, and an octopus that shows up in some unusual places.

The rhyming text is fun, and I can imagine a good parent/adult/caregiver can get a good rhythm going while reading it to entertain their audience, but the star of the show is Billups' illustrations. They're just great—there's plenty of color, while still feeling like you're looking through blue-green water. The octopus' tentacle alone is great to keep an eye out for, and I love Missus Bluffington's glasses. But there's plenty for a child's eyes to take in while listening to the text being read to/at them.

I can't forget to mention that it also includes some great back cover book blurbs that'll amuse the parent/reader, as well as a couple of visual jokes.

This is a fun little book that'll appeal to kids who love the look of Finding Nemo/Dory and aren't quite ready for that other city under the sea, Bikini Bottom. I had fun with it, and I bet adult readers for those kids will, too.