Ratings8
Average rating3.4
The island has a way of calling you home... Ten years ago, Emily Watson was on top of the world: a best-selling novel, a husband plucked from the pages of a magazine, and a one-way ticket to happily ever after. Now her perfect life has crumbled and Emily is left to pick up the pieces. So when her great-Aunt Bee invites her to spend the month of March on her beloved Bainbridge Island, Emily accepts, longing to be healed by the sea. As she begins researching her next book, Emily discovers a red velvet diary, dated 1943, whose contents reveal a startling secret that could change her life forever... A heart-breaking story of love, hope and second chances, from the international bestselling author of All the Flowers in Paris
Reviews with the most likes.
This was such a touching story and it really tugged at my heart. I usually don't like to read romance type stories but this one was not the typical romance. It starts with a young woman finding out her husband is leaving her for another woman. Emily, who is a writer, ends up going to stay with her great aunt for a month. She planned to spend some time there to heal and maybe write. Instead of writing she ends of reading. In the guest room at her aunts room she finds a red velvet diary and she can't resist reading it. On excursions with her aunt she meets people from the past and her memory of them begins to awaken. She learns some details about the story she is reading and begins to wonder if the story is actually true and if the people in it are closer to her than she thinks.
Books like this make me so mad. The entire plot is based on the fact that nobody will tell the heroine the truth about a diary she has found. The heroine's grandmother and others in the book know all of the plot's secrets, but when the heroine asks them directly, she is told repeatedly “this is your journey,” “you'll find the answers in time,” “it's not my story to tell,” etc. So she (very slowly) reads the diary so that the book will last for 300 pages.
Also, after learning how people in the past made devastating choices after jumping to conclusions, she does the exact same thing with the man she allegedly loves. Although there is so little interaction between the two characters and so little chemistry that it's hard to have any investment in their romance.
A frustrating and unsatisfying read.