Perhaps closer to 4.5 but probably because I was listening to it and had a difficult time telling when the perspective switched.
I loved the setting, fairytale/folklore elements, strong female characters, Jewish representation, and I want more fantasy books like this.

The story in the beginning about the fish dream was excellent.

The art is fantastic throughout.

I didn't love the inclusion or parallels to the animal families, it seems like a way to get my learners distracted making animal sounds rather than talking about who lives in their house or cares for them.

The art and story oscillated for me. But ultimately art doesn't have to be pretty and I really like McKean's style so I chose the three over two stars.

While the art was not always pretty it was always interesting and I enjoyed Dave McKean and Neil Gaiman's words. Sometimes it seemed like they were engaged but in banter. Also the repeated requests for the inclusion of a fish was amusing.

I'll come back and and add a note for most of the stories, but for the most part I enjoyed this.
I even liked the long introduction and the comments at the end.

Probably a 4 star read, but I was swooning over the chapter break pages that had quotes and lines from the song.

I also loved the small section where they talk about Mal's face.

Brilliant, reminds me of Gorey while still remaining its own

Love the mention of Hideo Kajima/Konami.

I knew hana could mean flower, cool to now know that hanami is flower watching, usually the cherry blossoms

I struggled with this one, I think I'll give it a re-read.

I hope this was cathartic for Bex to create but it was quite the mixed bag for me.

I had already read the last story of The Living and the Dead, which I thought was fantastic.

The other stories were also great; well constructed and I loved the silent movie era motif.

It says it's a fictionalization, although I don't know which aspects are fictional.

I enjoyed this, even though I was saddened that he left his wife and young son for so long.

Intriguing. It appears that I have read this about three years ago. I guess I liked it better then as I gave it 5 stars.

I really enjoyed Hill's forward and loved his characters. I thought the art was good.

I was saddened by the death of the officer on the highway, but then remembered that's the way of apocalyptic events.

I really liked this one, it made me feel and root for the characters. Templeton was fantastic.

I liked Toni more than I thought I would.

3.5
I drifted in and out for this one. Parts were pretty (such as the description of sea glass) but it didn't feel cohesive, likely just due to my foggy, allergy head. Maybe I'll give this one another listen. I liked the perspective of the fisherman.