This is in the same vein as Zen Science: Stop and Smell the Universe by John Javna, and annoyed me just as much.
It could have been much better organized. It lacks a table of contents.
Did appreciate the end where it talks about the half-life of knowledge, however I think it gets some of it wrong or perhaps it was just written poorly.
This book makes me think of that obnoxious kid in 7th grade science class that points out ‘I'm not actually touching you, nothing actually ever touches.'
I did appreciate it explaining some etymology of certain words.
So much better than Horns! (I know I shouldn't make comparisons.)
Hill gets the personality of the South right. My grandmother is from Louisiana and it felt so familiar.
It could only have gotten ‘more correct' if he worked in ‘warsh' (wash said with an ‘r' in it) somehow.
For a moment I cringed at the incest stereotype, but then thought that it wasn't necessarily a southern stereotype so much as what the horror genre covers and it takes place in the south.Loved Bami, wasn't surprised at her name but that's ok, and the part with her sister.The Ouija Board by Milton Bradley was a nice touch as I had had one in my childhood.
The best part of the book is when Joe Hill makes fun of Dean Koontz at the beginning, however this book is only about as good as Koontz's ‘Odd Thomas'.
Somethings were well done such as the grandmother and some of the double meanings, but not much surprised me and so much of it felt repetitive. I get it Ig is good at math and has a hard time breathing.
I'd still watch the movie of this. I did imagine parts of this book as portrayed by Radcliffe and most of it feels gratuitous. I also feel bad that he's portraying another not so loveable protagonist, but I'm curious how much of this will come off as The Dresden Files meets Law & Order.
I like her, as CA senator, CA attorney general, or as a district attorney. There are also things that are not my favorite, however they're not in the book.
Also, I dislike Kavanaugh.
Possibly just the audiobook, but at time it felt like it lacked fully structured transitions. I assume in print there were page breaks to serve as a visual transition.
I'm glad this book exists, I just expected more :/
The inside flap says 4-8yrs old and I think most four year old might catch on to what they're dressed as far as potential occupation, however I think it would have been even better for it to have been more overt, either as naming the occupation OR to have a representation of a woman dressed as her career so kids know that it can be more than just dress up. Also didn't love the page where they're all dressed as athletes because it looks like the girl playing basket ball is just wearing a basketball jersey— no shorts. But good job showing realistic cleats and the girl playing tennis is shown to be left handed.
Also could use a parent/teacher reading guide/information section in the back.
The story and its characters are imperfect. I felt that the pacing was decent, it's a little slow in the beginning, but I think that's due to its genre and is therefore fitting. The boyfriend is supportive, but not in the exact way that Cel wishes him to be, which I find true to life in the general way of boyfriend/girlfriend relations as well as with people experiencing mental illness and their support group.
I love this book's messages and I love the various volume that they are sounded at.
Positive LBGT message, sounded at a subtle volume: Holly and Gina are girlfriends. However, it's not a big deal, it's only implied that maybe Gina's father doesn't approve, and it could be cronyism equally as likely as bigotry — or that he just a stick in the mud and might not approve of anyone. Also they have a positive relationship, in which I didn't spot any overt stereotypes.
Positive mental health message, at a loud volume: over and over again it's written that it's ok to get and seek help, to start again, to try again, to engage in self care, and to take breaks. This is amazing and I don't think can be emphasized enough.
Cel was never labeled as crazy by anyone besides herself. And although what Cel was saying was implausible (eg ghost/haunting) her support group still believed in her and labeled her feelings as valid.
Additional message that the field of medicine (and arguably psychology and where they intersect) has a very messy past. Especially when it come to women and people of color...and the poor. I highly enjoyed the afterward