Probably a 3.5. A lot of “not like the other girls” in the way she talks about the other girls, which was hard to read about. Her revelation about her experience with Hef was really interesting though and I think she worded that really really well.
I also thought it was sad and interesting that she never called the relationship with Hef abusive. It definitely was a textbook abusive relationship.
Unfortunately, I agree with the other reviews here in that something about this failed to connect. I read this way after COVID lockdowns but still HATED this hero. I know that teen novels are all about growth but NO ONE was as hard on him as they should've been in my opinion. I also thought there was a lot of built up between the mother-daughter relationship and just not enough was resolved. This book just tackled a lot of issues that it didn't work through well enough for me to rate this well.
This book was a strong okay. It was interesting learning a bit more about Lutheran theology but I thought the author's examples and some of his tangents were a bit narrow minded for me. I think he was reaching in a lot of these examples used to try to explain the 12 icons and it made a bit of it difficult to read.
I thought this was just okay, but it was interesting and engaging. It got a little frustrating how much could've been explained because people were keeping secrets (even though that was also explained) and the pacing was a little slow at parts. Overall interesting though and way better than Addie LaRue (the writing style very much reminded me of it).
2.5 stars rounded up because I finished in one day. This was rough and very similar to every other book with these tropes. Doesn't help that I just read “she started it” this year which worked better for me so I couldn't help but compare. Is there some rule that every character has to be unlikable in these types of books?
Again this is the type of historical romance I really like!! I'm not really looking forward to the third book because the last brother is meh to me but I AM looking forward to the spin off.
As far as this book, I didn't like it as much as the first. I actually think the pacing of it worked for me– but Oswald was just mehh.
Like the first book, this was very much a page-turner. Had a lot of the same themes as the first one as well. I found the main character frustrating at times but understand that its part of her personality due to her background. I think the end was consolidated and just wrapped up way too quickly. The therapy sessions at the end made a lot of progress VERY quickly which was weird considering how slow paced the first 2/3 of the book was and I wish we would've gotten more detail on her character growth. Overall though this is an author I will automatically read.
I really wanted to like this book and was excited about it but I thought it was just way too wide-sweeping and too surface level. He tried to go into deeper topics/mention issues that have been going on for a long time (this isn't a new phenomenon) but he just...didn't do a great job. I also didn't know much about him and found him to be a bit vague about his personal upbringing as well.
I found it hard to not compare this to books like “Jesus and John Wayne” and “The making of Biblical Womanhood” which I feel covered their topics MUCH more thoroughly and completely.