2.5 rounded up for the writing style and holiday/winter vibes.
This particular sister/suspense sub plot wasn't for me personally. I had a hard time connecting with this book and found it very boring but I absolutely loved the first one. I'm looking forward to the next book and looking forward to learning more about Claire.
This also gets more points because I always appreciate more feminist elements in my Christian fiction and I am happy about that. I hope in the next book we get even more pushback on how the mom in the series is handling this death bed promise + Claire in Scotland (so terrible!!).
I finished this the morning my family and I are about to become official members of our local Lutheran church so good timing! My church was doing a Bible study from this author (another one) so I decided to check this out bc it's available on KU.
I thought this was so encouraging!! A good reminder of Gods promises and instructions. The instructions part was never shame-y and the author redirected us to Christ often. Overall I would recommend.