Rob

I listened to the audiobook on Libby and the Author has quite a power yet smooth voice. It's also a very short audiobook.

It was a very cute story.

When I read when I was younger I only focused on the Romeo and Juliet stuff that I completely forgot about all the stuff that happens with the horses/Aunt Rebecca.

I completely forgot about what this story of the series about and it's one of my favorites of the series.

I have totally forgotten a lot about this series.

I was starting to remember that Ivy's dad was her bio dad and I couldn't figure out how the girls found out until the end of this book.

Another great story.

A great middle-grade book and part of a series I loved growing up.

This book had a very 90's feel for me. I absolutely loved it. It was heartbreaking and heart warming.

Great end to this series and a nice set up for the next one.

I'm so not ready for The Last Olympian due to some things in this book but I can't stop wanting more.

I'm excited to see where the story goes from here. It's been slowly ramping up and I'm ready for more of it.

Awesome story.

I loved this story it was very thrilling. I was a bit spoiled by other media but it was better than I could have imagined.

This book was thrilling to the very end and I loved it.

Very good loved it to the very end.

I read this a lot as a kid and it was fun to reread these stories.

A great story for kids to read.

Perfect for kids who want to get a do one day.

I wasn't expecting such a focus on gender in this book but it was very informative.

I love this book it was filled with sadness and the small bit of hope and I nearly cried at the end.

The ending was great and very action packed. However, it does sort of feel like a copy paste of the first book. You can pretty much get the storyline based on the fact that both have two main male characters, one of which has amnesia, with a main female character as the other main males love interest. However, I much prefer the romance between Frank and Hazel more than the romance in the first book. I like the fact both liked the other but were quite shy about it. The first book's romance felt a bit forced after reading this book, as Piper seems obsessed with her fake memories of Jason. However, I am excited to continue the series as soon as I get the other books.

The Audio book was awesome.

I didn't like the story at first but the more I read the more I got into it. A perfect story to read with Autoboyography by Christina Lauren.

I enjoy the story very thoroughly and have never read a story with a character with amnesia. I've been favoring multiperspective stories lately and this was excellent.

Second Read Through: I reading this after reading the Percy Jackson Series makes this book even better.

Warning: this text may contain spoilers I love the back and forth from the past to the present. Then it taking a break in the middle and then going between Belle and the perspective of the beast to the village/her father's perspective. It was quite the retelling of the classic story I know.