It's a pretty good story and pretty creepy. The main character is unreliable as you slowly find out which I think makes the story a bit better. The ending is pretty scary in a different way as you realize Ed maybe has the same condition as his father or that's what is implied at least.
The second time I read this It was on Audio and was pretty good.
I loved this book. I love the twist and turns as well as the misdirection. The only things I wish was different is that there was an inkling that Ruby was The Gemini Thief and the fact Tanks was revealed to be missing before he went missing in the Elizabeth Letters.
-Updated Views as of Nov 16,2023-
The more I read this book the more I fall in love with Aulus, Tank, Glads, Nick, and Thea. They are all searching for answers and questioning the adults around them as they are graduating high school (minus Nick). The more I reread this the more I see how Ruby was the Gemini thief even though everyone thought the Gemini thief would be a male. Little hints of her being the thief. Chapter 40 gives me goosebumps everytime I read it. The last Elizabeth letters make my heart pound. I am officially changing my four stars to Five because I love this story so much and can't wait to read it again.