Brian
Interesting premise, but tedious execution. Every other chapter jumps back in time which breaks any narrative urgency. The heroine is the best fighter ever, a brilliant sleuth, a penniless orphan. She doesn't feel like a real person.
The setting is interesting though, and I almost care about several of the characters.
Interesting premise, but tedious execution. Every other chapter jumps back in time which breaks any narrative urgency. The heroine is the best fighter ever, a brilliant sleuth, a penniless orphan. She doesn't feel like a real person.
The setting is interesting though, and I almost care about several of the characters.
Dnf at 25% complete. I suppose it could get better, but somehow we already have the incredibly tired tropes of
- Hero exiled after traffic mistake
- Weak younger sibling who has to grow up in a hurry
- Sturdy, dependable ex soldier who is unfazed by shrewish heroine, and falls in love
- The inn is crowded and has only 1 bed
- A wise animal appears and leads the hunter to wisdom
I'm honestly impressed at the density of cliche in so short a span of pages. The characters felt like they were being put through the paces of a just so story. They had no life of their own.
Dnf at 25% complete. I suppose it could get better, but somehow we already have the incredibly tired tropes of
- Hero exiled after traffic mistake
- Weak younger sibling who has to grow up in a hurry
- Sturdy, dependable ex soldier who is unfazed by shrewish heroine, and falls in love
- The inn is crowded and has only 1 bed
- A wise animal appears and leads the hunter to wisdom
I'm honestly impressed at the density of cliche in so short a span of pages. The characters felt like they were being put through the paces of a just so story. They had no life of their own.
I mostly enjoyed the book. I liked the alternating chapters of history and narrative. The main character was both sympathetic and aggravating (which I like - I'm so tired of the trope of the perfect hero unjustly exiled). I did not really enjoy the big twist at the end though. It felt like deus ex machina, but maybe I was just too thick in not trying to work out the puzzle as it was revealed.
I mostly enjoyed the book. I liked the alternating chapters of history and narrative. The main character was both sympathetic and aggravating (which I like - I'm so tired of the trope of the perfect hero unjustly exiled). I did not really enjoy the big twist at the end though. It felt like deus ex machina, but maybe I was just too thick in not trying to work out the puzzle as it was revealed.
I wanted to like this book. I'm a sucker for regency romance, witches, weird magic, and plucky heroines. The writing, though, gave everything away. Nothing was earned, no discoveries were made. I dnf'd when the grandmother showed up in the second chapter to explain that she is literally called a "Honey Witch" because...of magical honey. Emotional moments are discarded almost as soon as they're introduced and foreshadowing lasts barely through the paragraph in which it's introduced.
I wanted to like this book. I'm a sucker for regency romance, witches, weird magic, and plucky heroines. The writing, though, gave everything away. Nothing was earned, no discoveries were made. I dnf'd when the grandmother showed up in the second chapter to explain that she is literally called a "Honey Witch" because...of magical honey. Emotional moments are discarded almost as soon as they're introduced and foreshadowing lasts barely through the paragraph in which it's introduced.
First impression: Ready Player One for gamers. (That's not a compliment). Second impression: actually deep, and I love that sassy cat.
I was close to dropping the book after the first few pages. The constant "hilarious" in-game descriptions were really off putting. The whole premise of "what if a regular person was dropped into Warcraft!" was pretty dull, too.
I kept pushing through though because I'm a sucker for a good cat character, and Princess Donut is excellent. I stayed because I do enjoy a good power leveling fantasy when the characters are also good. By the mid point I was detecting some interesting themes on voyeurism and capitalist exploitation.
For the record, though, Matthew Woodring Stover did a much better job on those topics with the Legacy of Cain series - grittier, more complex, and ultimately more horrifying.
So far, I can say I enjoy DCC, but I doubt it'll have a permanent spot on my shelf.
First impression: Ready Player One for gamers. (That's not a compliment). Second impression: actually deep, and I love that sassy cat.
I was close to dropping the book after the first few pages. The constant "hilarious" in-game descriptions were really off putting. The whole premise of "what if a regular person was dropped into Warcraft!" was pretty dull, too.
I kept pushing through though because I'm a sucker for a good cat character, and Princess Donut is excellent. I stayed because I do enjoy a good power leveling fantasy when the characters are also good. By the mid point I was detecting some interesting themes on voyeurism and capitalist exploitation.
For the record, though, Matthew Woodring Stover did a much better job on those topics with the Legacy of Cain series - grittier, more complex, and ultimately more horrifying.
So far, I can say I enjoy DCC, but I doubt it'll have a permanent spot on my shelf.
The premise was interesting, but the characters and world building were completely implausible.
I know it's sci-fi. I love sci fi and fantasy, so I'm used to some level of impossible to make the story work. It's only interesting though if the people are still recognizably human. In the world of scythe, teenagers can execute strangers in cold blood and not be completely fucked up. The rich elites somehow allowed a system that renders them as vulnerable to death as anyone else. People have a perfect system of wealth redistribution, and immunity to natural death, but somehow choose to keep unlimited reproduction while agreeing to random violent death. The reapers use knives, and drowning, and fire to kill people instead of something quiet and humane?
The whole thing reels of "I have a thought experiment and I'm going to ignore absolutely everything that makes it implausible"
For context, The Culture books by Iain M Banks are set in a world with hyper intelligent AI, immunity to most natural death, and have a post scarcity economy. The people are still recognizably people, and the stories are still interesting because they have recognizable reactions to horrible situations.
The premise was interesting, but the characters and world building were completely implausible.
I know it's sci-fi. I love sci fi and fantasy, so I'm used to some level of impossible to make the story work. It's only interesting though if the people are still recognizably human. In the world of scythe, teenagers can execute strangers in cold blood and not be completely fucked up. The rich elites somehow allowed a system that renders them as vulnerable to death as anyone else. People have a perfect system of wealth redistribution, and immunity to natural death, but somehow choose to keep unlimited reproduction while agreeing to random violent death. The reapers use knives, and drowning, and fire to kill people instead of something quiet and humane?
The whole thing reels of "I have a thought experiment and I'm going to ignore absolutely everything that makes it implausible"
For context, The Culture books by Iain M Banks are set in a world with hyper intelligent AI, immunity to most natural death, and have a post scarcity economy. The people are still recognizably people, and the stories are still interesting because they have recognizable reactions to horrible situations.
Charming book. It does a good job of providing an alien perspective that feels both approachable and very...alien. There were some major plot holes, and the main character is a little too good at everything, but I ultimately loved the characters and wanted to see how everything worked out.
Charming book. It does a good job of providing an alien perspective that feels both approachable and very...alien. There were some major plot holes, and the main character is a little too good at everything, but I ultimately loved the characters and wanted to see how everything worked out.
