Listener

I loved the stories, but the audiobook was hard to parse- not enough pause between stories

Oh damn

I was enjoying this and the art style, but we do not get to have an honest to sa rape and then just gloss over it like it didn't happen. I'd like to read the next one to see if they cover that, but if it's just a “Whoops, my bad bruh” then I'm not interested.

Wowza

I want to like this plot, but I feel like it's approaching it from a very shallow understanding of what it's like to not identify as male or female. I want to read the rest of them, but I'm not sure I'm enjoying it.

Still Not sure where this is going?

As a hardcore fan since the series first came out, I'm delighted to say that this graphic novel adaptation was wonderful! It got the entire feeling of the series, not to mention the fact that the art style fits perfectly with the common fanart style of the Warriors Fandom! There were characters I could recognize by sight, even though a few weren't how I imagined them. It feels as though it were written and illustrated by the fandom, rather than the vague unknowing I used to get from the Warriors Manga.

I highly recommend this for any fan of the series or newcomers wanting to join the clans!

Trigger Warning: Body Horror. Damn, the body horror. Not for the faint of heart or those made woozy by viscera.

There is a kind of horror in loving someone, and a kind of love in knowing somebody's true horrors.

I loved it in some places more than I expected, and disliked it in other places I had not. Overall, a great book with excellent world building, but a very frustrating MC

Not my favorite of the books so far, I'm a bit skeeved by Malcolm and Lyra's crushes, and by the traumatic experience near the end. I o want to keep seeing how the story goes, but it certainly was a vast difference from how I initially experienced the world Pullman writes.

Darker than expected, but a fabulous read! I felt the character's emotions so strongly!

Artstyle was great! I just really don't like Jane Austen.

I'm not entirely pleased with how this ended, but I do think that it's interesting how it formed a circle. Two girls emotionally jailed by the fathers, controlled by their fathers wills and moral opinions.

Devestatingly good.

It was good, but I didn't realize it was part of a series I've yet to read! ^_^”

A little too much tell and not show at the beginning, but I did wind up rather liking the world and characters by the end!

I liked this one! I look forward to seeing more from this author.

This is going right on the favorites shelf with the first one! This sequel was delightful, and I love how the characters tell it. It has shifting perspective, but not first person, so it didn't feel as jarring as switching from mind to mind. I really loved getting to explore more about Dami- my favorite character from the first book - and getting to really explore their mind and past. The new characters fit well into the world, and the plot is a wild ride that's never boring.

I've never in my 27 years on this planet wanted to read Pride and Prejudice. This book was so well written that it makes me WANT to read the original to compare scenes. Truly well done.

I really liked this one! It has a cozy fireside heart warming style.

Okay. Okay. Uh.
Okay.
That one was bizarre. I spent most of the first half of the book wanting to listen to anything else, but being too curious to stop it. The captain uhhh, well. He's very horny. In general. Mostly for salt.
He has some wacky fever dreams that had me cringed out for hours, and a certain scene betwixt him and his ship had me recoiling in alarm.

But the ending of it was actually really solid. It drew back into the air of an introspective horror and broke into the nitty gritty of what made a person a monster and what made them a man. I rather liked the ending, but I had to swim through a lot of disturbingly salty rats to get there.

Also, adding this after remembering: There's some rancidly bad outdated perceptions of the Romani people in this, and includes mentions of slavery and sexual abuse of slaves. It's period accurate, but still. Exonyms abound.

I loved the story! I had a bit of trouble with the audiobook narrators. There just seemed to be a lot of tones they missed? Like a dark comment would be said cheerfully or a sarcastic one said normally. I kind of want to reread this as a physical copy and follow my own mental tones?

I remember reading this when it first started coming out online! Glad to see it in physical form, and eager to catch back up on a forgotten but well enjoyed series.

The pacing was odd in this series.

I liked this one better than the first one! The world building was excellent, and the characters a bit more likeable! I was yet again frustrated by the “JUST TELL HIM” Aspect of the story, and by both characters thinking they weren't good enough for the other. But Clem was a marvelous character, and represented people like him very well!