I admit to being a little afraid to read Pan's sophomore novel as I read her first during my Printz year and ADORED it. She is a gorgeous writer and her words are so beautiful and luminous - like the moon!
But I loved this take on Romeo and Juliet just as much. It's a lot dreamy and sad but so worth it.
I have complicated feelings about this one. I LOVED the magic(s) systems and worldbuilding but I found some of the characters a little lacking. Part of me wishes I had read this 20 years ago. Not because it's for unsophisticated readers but just that my reading tastes have changed over that time. I like more female characters for me. But the plotting, magic, and world building is SO COOL that I totally get the hype for Sanderson.
I loved Keefe's book Say Nothing so when this came out I was intrigued but then not sure I would be interested. I was wrong. This was fascinating and enraging! It's one of those books where you find yourself running to the next room to tell someone something you just learned in the book - They wanted to sell Oxy to CHILDREN! They didn't do any studies to see if it's addictive and said they did! They knew that it was TWO TIMES as powerful as morphine!
I really appreciated the amount of research put into the book and how clear he was about his process and sources. I loved that he had an independent fact-checker for the book. (Did you know most nonfiction isn't fact-checked? https://www.npr.org/2019/06/08/730898366/checking-facts-in-nonfiction)
Finally, it seems harsh to call the entire Sackler family evil but I can't think of a different word for it.
This is one that's going to stick with me.
I LOVED it. Not only is the art gorgeous - I want to live in those color palettes - but the story is excellent. I think it's a great interrogation of heroism, war, and violence. I was reading another review where the person said they wanted to know what the Ornu had “done” to be treated as enemies or second-class citizens. The answer is, like so many real-life examples, that they did nothing. Their “crime” was being in the way of colonization and power and empire.
The authors clearly took so much care into all the details of this work and it is exceptional. Highly recommended for anyone who has ever wanted to be a hero.
I loved Pet but I think I loved this even more! Everything about it is so well done: the nuance with which Emezi talks about protest and freedom, their refusal to give easy answers to real world problems, and the warning of uses of power. It's just so good.
Also? Going to go ahead and say one of the best openings to a teen book ever. So freaking good!
I think this is a great pick for readers looking for a short mystery with multiple queer characters. While it is a mystery, it's more contemplative and emotional than something like One of Us is Lying, so it's more readers who want the mystery aspects of it, but are more interested in the aftermath of the lives touched by violence.