| #2 |  Vespertine
| 4.27 |
| #4 |  Our Last Echoes
| 3.63 |
| #5 |  Goddess of Filth
| 3.16 |
| #6 |  The Southern Book Club's Guide to Slaying Vampires
| 3.8 |
| #7 |  We Sold Our Souls
| 3.72 |
| #9 |  Mapping the Interior
| 3.82 |
| #10 |  Gallant
| 3.78 |
| #11 |  City of Ghosts
| 3.69 |
| #12 |  This Thing Between Us
| 3.75 |
| #13 |  Such a Pretty Smile
| 3.33 |
| #14 |  Stolen Tongues
| 3.56 |
| #15 |  The Babysitters Coven
| 3.55 |
| #16 |  Lair of Dreams
| 3.94 |
| #17 |  Locke & Key, Volume 2: Head Games
| 4.25 |
| #18 |  The Kurosagi Corpse Delivery Service, Volume 10
| 3.79 |
| #19 |  Angelfall
| 3.92 |
| #20 |  The Bone Witch
| 3.91 |
| #21 |  Kill Creek
| 3.68 |
| #22 |  Pet Sematary
| 3.95 |
| #23 |  The Darkest Minds
| 3.79 |
| #24 |  Empire of the Vampire
| 4.43 |
| #25 |  Certain Dark Things
| 3.73 |
| #26 |  Something is Killing the Children, Vol. 4 | 4.53 |
| #27 |  Mary
| 4.01 |
| #28 |  Dark Stars
| 2.67 |
| #29 |  Hidden Pictures
| 3.98 |
| #30 |  The Pallbearers Club: A Novel
| 3.28 |
| #31 |  Come Closer
| 3.58 |
| #32 |  Chain of Thorns
| 3.89 |
| #33 |  The Angel Maker
| 3.14 |
| #34 |  The Spite House
| 3.62 |
| #35 |  Delicious Monsters
| 4.3 |
| #36 |  Where Darkness Blooms
| 3.5 |
| #37 |  Sister, Maiden, Monster
| 3.86 |
| #38 |  The London Séance Society
| 3.31 |
| #39 |  Weyward
| 4.05 |
| #40 |  The God of Endings
| 3.85 |
| #41 |  The Witch and the Vampire
| 3.33 |
| #42 |  Monstrilio
| 4.1 |
| #43 |  Piñata
| 3.68 |
| #44 |  The Haunting of Alejandra
| 3.64 |
| #45 |  Kingdom of the Feared
| 3.76 |
| #46 |  The Weight of Blood
| 4.3 |
| #47 |  Fairy Tale
| 3.94 |
| #48 |  All of Our Demise
| 3.72 |
| #49 |  Belladonna
| 3.85 |
| #50 |  The Serpent & the Wings of Night
| 4.04 |
| #51 |  The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches
| 4.12 |
| #52 |  Spell Bound
| 3.98 |
| #53 |  The Lake House
| 4 |
| #54 |  The Honeys
| 3.81 |
| #55 |  The Book Eaters
| 3.61 |
| #56 |  Just Like Home
| 3.48 |
| #57 |  Graveyard of Lost Children
| 3.5 |
| #58 |  Daphne
| 3.33 |
| #59 |  The Summer Hikaru Died, Vol. 1
| 4.33 |
| #60 |  The Coldest Girl in Coldtown
| 3.71 |
| #61 |  Sekolah Sihir Hecate
| 3.66 |
| #62 |  Rebel Belle
| 3.58 |
| #64 |  Dark Lover
| 3.72 |
| #65 |  Everything the Darkness Eats
| 2.89 |
| #66 |  A Turn of Light
| 3.5 |
| #67 |  Silver Nitrate
| 3.7 |
| #68 |  Her Little Flowers
| 3 |
| #69 |  Camp Damascus
| 3.84 |
| #70 |  The Beast You Are: Stories
| 3.13 |
| #71 |  Burn the Negative
| 3.41 |
| #72 |  Mister Magic
| 3.35 |
| #73 |  Looking Glass Sound
| 3.54 |
| #74 |  I Feed Her to the Beast and the Beast Is Me
| 3.96 |
