Important topic, good to have actual numbers laid out, but all throughout you can tell this was written by a man. There's very little said about the unpaid, unseen labor (almost always of women) required for a lot of the “utopian” pasts listed, which would be the same in the utopian futures envisioned in the book. It very cursorily notes the concept in a few instances and then frustratingly dismisses it and moves on. Yes, reduce consumption and stop producing wild amounts of garbage and excess, but consider the other side of that lifestyle adjustment and who will be darning those longer wearing socks and washing those non-disposable dishes. It doesn't have to be women, but the way things are these days it usually is - what if these dudely perspectives encouraged the other environmentally minded dudes to take on those tasks themselves rather than only looking at the big picture economics of it? To make real change, both are necessary.
It's all correct and interesting information that's important to be talking about, but I also didn't necessarily learn tons - I already know most of how the systems are fucked up. It's an interesting spin on the topic, something of a reversal of how things seem to often default to being seen from the heterosexual as base assumption. I wish there had been some deeper exploration, and perhaps a few more varied perspectives from additional authors.
The older I get, the less I believe in respecting elders just because they're old. The aged have really pushed their agenda of forced status based on smoke and mirrors for a long time, and frankly, I'm over it. Whenever I pass the age of someone I looked up to or got advice from (especially if it was a sort of “you'll understand when you're older, poppet” format) I realize that I don't know anything yet, and neither did they, it was all hollow bravado. That said, this book was refreshing, because it didn't use dumping on younger people to build up the old. It just talked about living well and doing what you can for as long as you can. Recommended for all ages.
In general I find apocalypse scenarios in media to be wildly boring and unimaginative. This story addressed some (but certainly not all) of the standard tropes of the genre that make it feel unrealistic and dull to me. I appreciated that it went far enough into the future to be outside the panic of a pivotal moment and into the time when the “new” reality has settled in, without going full Walking Dead with making that panic level of existence last forever. The narrative managed the jumping back and forth in time well. I found most of the “twists” to be predictable but I don't usually read specifically for gotcha moments so that's fine with me.
I kept this on as mindless background noise far longer than I paid attention to it, so I give it some credit for that. But I kept zoning out and realizing I hadn't been listening for probably whole chapters, and when I realized I didn't care enough to go back and restart those, it was time to turn it off.
My ability to read about the trials of young white men out to find themselves seems to hover close to zero these days. Full disclosure, this review is based on only a portion of the book, I could not finish it. It does contain some beautiful descriptions of the desert, and if someone felt like creating an edited version that is only those parts I think it would be a worthwhile read. Unfortunately they're spread out between sections of eye rolling bildungsroman and rants against such offenders as old people, young people, women who are prostitutes, women who are not prostitutes, gardeners, and Native Americans. No thanks.