Emma Deplores puts it best in her review.

Not convinced of the diagnosis here. It just doesn't make sense with some of the stories in the book.

I wish I had listened to the audiobook of this instead of reading it. After reading other reviews, it seems like I would have enjoyed that more.

Might be one of my newest all time favorites. So so good!

As someone that weighs far more than she should ... I had a hard time getting through this book. I wish Gay would just own some of her own crap. And maybe I'm fooling myself, but I don't think that other people are looking at me and judging me as much as I am them.

I flew through the first half of this book - then it was pure determination that got me through the second half.

Towles is an awesome storyteller, if a little long winded. I would have given more stars if it were 100 pages shorter.

Not my typical kind of book, or so I thought it wasn't. Sure glad I listened to a friend who INSISTED I read this. Phenomenal.

I can't give this book enough stars. The audio was amazing, but I also ended up purchasing a physical copy before I finished so I could go back and read my favorite bits.

LOVE. LOVE. LOVE this story. The book is in desperate need of editing for grammatical issues, but the story is AMAZING.

This one had a lot of potential. It was a real page-turner for me until about 3/4 way in. I just didn't care for where it ended up in the end.

I really enjoyed this thriller, but I'm not sure why the last little bit was necessary. It was like the author was trying too hard to make one last twist. It just felt forced and rushed. Otherwise, it was pretty good!

Reread in 2015 - didn't enjoy nearly as much as I did in high school :(

Absolutely the most depressing book I've ever read. I wanted to put it down because it was absolutely heart wrenching but I was so hooked on the characters that I couldn't stop.

Hated it in high school... I guess it just needed 20 years to grow on me. :-P