| #2 |  It
| 4.07 |
| #3 |  The Institute
| 4.02 |
| #4 |  Chasing the Boogeyman
| 3.76 |
| #5 |  Mexican Gothic
| 3.77 |
| #6 |  We Have Always Lived in the Castle
| 3.95 |
| #7 |  Hidden Pictures
| 3.96 |
| #8 |  Lone Women
| 3.83 |
| #9 |  Bunny
| 3.56 |
| #10 |  We Sold Our Souls
| 3.73 |
| #11 |  Horrorstör
| 3.57 |
| #12 |  FantasticLand
| 3.91 |
| #13 |  Slewfoot: A Tale of Bewitchery
| 4.39 |
| #14 |  The Paleontologist
| 3.42 |
| #15 |  Mary
| 4.01 |
| #16 |  The Mist
| 3.71 |
| #17 |  Home Before Dark
| 3.9 |
| #18 |  My Darling Girl
| 3.67 |
| #19 |  The Lost Village
| 3.33 |
| #20 |  The Reformatory
| 4.43 |
| #21 |  Silver Nitrate
| 3.7 |
| #22 |  Run
| 3.43 |
| #23 |  Vampires of El Norte
| 3.84 |
| #24 |  The Devil Takes You Home
| 3.76 |
| #25 |  Old Soul
| 0 |
| #26 |  Tender Is the Flesh
| 3.73 |
| #27 |  You Like It Darker
| 4.11 |
| #29 |  Her Little Flowers
| 3 |
| #30 |  The Night House
| 3.03 |
| #31 |  Nothing But Blackened Teeth
| 2.72 |
| #32 |  The September House
| 3.88 |
| #33 |  Incidents Around the House
| 3.84 |
| #34 |  Nestlings
| 4.13 |
| #35 |  Just Like Home
| 3.51 |
| #36 |  Dearest
| 3.83 |
| #37 |  Monstrilio
| 4.17 |
