i honestly keep coming back here to change my rating, if i could find something that was problematic or i didnt like but tbh, there was nothing as such. the other books in the series are not so good and meh, but this one was perfect. the chemistry, the love, the characters, the romance.

this one didnt have what the first did.

second book by this author and i have come to accept that this author's style doesnt match my taste

I cant believe this book has 4.5 ratings
It felt like something id read on wattpad when i was 14
also no chemistry or sexual tension/spark of any sort between the characters
dnfed at 66%

i have to say, something about pakistani dramas (the old meaningful ones) and now books makes me want to claw at my skin for how brilliantly realistic and painful they are. This was heart wrenching and i wish to never read it again.

the only reason i suppose this book is my favorite is because i fell head over in love with josh im, even though he seems mediocre but so fucking hot. thats it.

i think lynn painter should stick to y/a

not going to lie, i was aiming for 4/5 stars up until i found out the real reason simon was killed (OR, spoiler alert, killed himself to get back at bunch of other kids who didnt include him in). I was rooting for either of them to be the murdere but i was really disappointed.

started out with such great potential, became so redundant and the plot twist was fucking bullshit and lazy. i apologize to the author but all the effort the protagonist put was washed away by a white boy who thinks he helped her and now somehow owns her.

the book was great in context of highlighting real life problems such as manipulative, controlling parents, deadbeat fathers, sef-loathing, homophobia in many different ways where people think they're just being funny, eating disorders (in a way?) but the story itself didnt do much for me

I dont understand why do all the characters in ali hazelwood's books dont like sex...

I'm unsure of what to rate this..because i dont know if i liked it or not.

everything went over my head but i did feel really sad about her husband's death and her daughter's illness

the title and the summary were not exactly an indication for the plot itself. I was confused about where is the “lie” considering she just conceals her real identity rather than anything else

Though it felt like reading a personal diary at most, but it was beautifully written. I cried, smiled and chuckled, felt related to a couple of moments shared between mother and daughter.

4.5/5