Baptism

This originally appeared at The Irresponsible Reader.
—
It's been awhile since I've read a book on baptism – it's been awhile since I've seen a new one published, too (but maybe I stopped paying attention), so when I saw this on NetGalley, I had to take a chance. I'm very glad I did. Richard discusses in his introduction that questions about this sacrament are some of the most frequently asked to Presbyterian (and, I assume, Reformed) pastors. Sadly, they're usually asked when pastors can't give the kind of answers they should – at least based on his experience.

He begins looking at the meaning of Baptism – both the Greek terms translated as “baptism” and the sacrament. He does so very well, covering all the bases. Following that he moves to the method of baptism – how should the water be applied? Once he's finished with these matters he moves into the more complicated question – who should be baptised? He begins with the “household” baptisms in the New Testament before turning to the objections and arguments of Baptist and baptistic brothers. He not only examines and explains them fairly well, he responds to them in an irenic manner, but not giving an inch to them.

The conclusion, “What Can We Take Away from All This” is just fantastic. Richard's meditations on how our baptisms should shape our lives and our faith, to build our faith and give us assurance. It's easily worth half of whatever you pay for the book, and maybe more.

This is probably not a book that will convince any detractors. It may not be enough to convince the earnest seeker. But it will explain the basics for each topic considered. It will demonstrate the systematic and biblical basis for Richard's positions exists and they aren't mere tradition. These are outlines to be filled in with further reflection, reading and research by the reader.

Along those lines, each chapter could really use a “For Further Reading” to help the reader get deeper into the topics covered – or one at the end of the book. But I do think as each chapter is so topic-focused, it'd be very helpful. As good as each chapter is, they are just an overview. Not every reader is going to want to go deeper into, say, the mode/method of baptism but they might want to spend more time on the meaning of Baptism, or his response to Baptist interpretations of Jeremiah 31. For example, I think I agree with his differing from Murray on the former – but I'd like to read more about that, if it's possible.

Richard's tone throughout is gracious, kind, yet unbending. It's not easy to putt off in print, especially on a topic like Baptism. There were many times he could've gone for the jugular, rhetorically speaking. He never did, trusting that the arguments would carry the day. And, in my not so humble opinion, he's right to trust that.

Gracious, encouraging, thorough and easy to read – this introduction to “the waters that divide” Christians is just what you want in a book on this topic. But more than those, it's deeply biblical in nature. Richard's focus in bringing the light of the canon to this topic, and he succeeds there. I strongly encourage you to read it.


Disclaimer: I received this eARC from Reformation Trust Publishing via NetGalley in exchange for this post – thanks to both for this.