| #2 |  Rock Paper Scissors
| 3.83 |
| #3 |  Local Woman Missing
| 3.92 |
| #4 |  Home Before Dark
| 3.89 |
| #5 |  The It Girl
| 3.51 |
| #6 |  The Last Flight
| 3.85 |
| #7 |  The Night She Disappeared
| 3.83 |
| #8 |  All Good People Here
| 3.47 |
| #9 |  The Book of Cold Cases
| 3.61 |
| #10 |  Daisy Darker
| 3.78 |
| #11 |  Every Last Secret
| 4.12 |
| #12 |  Little Secrets
| 3.88 |
| #13 |  Long Bright River
| 4.14 |
| #14 |  Reckless Girls
| 3.09 |
| #15 |  Things We Do in the Dark
| 3.86 |
| #16 |  The Night Swim
| 4.08 |
| #17 |  Unspeakable Things
| 3.5 |
| #18 |  False Witness
| 4.09 |
| #19 |  Run Rose Run
| 3.4 |
| #20 |  The Shadows: A Novel
| 3.75 |
| #21 |  The End of Her
| 3.58 |
| #22 |  The Lies I Tell
| 4.29 |
| #23 |  What Lies in the Woods
| 3.87 |
| #24 |  Twenty Years Later
| 4.06 |
| #25 |  Every Last Fear
| 3.67 |
| #26 |  In the Woods
| 3.72 |
| #27 |  For Your Own Good
| 3.74 |
| #28 |  The Final Girl Support Group
| 3.42 |
| #29 |  The Violence
| 3.94 |
| #30 |  Hidden Pictures
| 3.95 |
| #31 |  The Hacienda
| 3.88 |
| #32 |  Killers of a Certain Age
| 3.58 |
| #33 |  The House Across the Lake
| 3.51 |
| #34 |  Truly Devious
| 3.86 |
| #35 |  Final Girls
| 3.52 |
| #36 |  The New House
| 3.29 |
| #37 |  Dead Silence
| 3.75 |
| #38 |  Death on the Nile
| 3.99 |
| #39 |  The Broken Girls
| 3.94 |
| #40 |  Bunny
| 3.57 |
| #41 |  The Turn of the Key
| 3.8 |
| #42 |  American Psycho
| 3.63 |
| #43 |  Feed Them Silence
| 3.35 |
| #44 |  The Coworker
| 3.44 |
| #45 |  Just Another Missing Person
| 3.53 |
| #46 |  Silver Nitrate
| 3.73 |
| #47 |  Murder in the Family
| 3.83 |
| #48 |  How to Sell a Haunted House
| 3.78 |
| #49 |  Middle of the Night
| 3.7 |
| #50 |  Incidents Around the House
| 3.76 |
| #51 |  A Question of Sanity A Question of Sanity
| 0 |
| #52 |  The Last House on Needless Street
| 3.92 |
| #53 |  Tender Is the Flesh
| 3.73 |
| #54 |  Not My Baby Not My Baby
| 3.5 |
| #55 |  Ask for Andrea
| 3.73 |
