This was amzing. I've been looking forward to this book for a long time. I really enjoyed the art and the importance of stories, the comparative religion was one of my favorite themes.
There are a few things however that interrupted my enjoyment of the book. In the beginning of the book it was a little difficult to follow the order of events and the jumping in the story, but it was manageable. What was bigger than that was the settling was jumbled – for the majority of the book appears to take place hundreds of years ago, but then later in the book they appear to be in modern times which is just confusing, and thus (for me) frustrating.
Also did I miss something about her biological son, how does an empty crib automatically mean death? I mean you never gave up on Habibi, but are so quick to just give up on the child that you had recently had a change of heart about?
Heavy topics, race, sex, rape, gender... All of which he may not have gotten correct, but it does give one something to think about.
I scored each comic I read from 0-5, then averaged, I ended up with about 2.6, however I'm giving it the 2 stars instead of three because I'm additionally disappointed with the way it was set up by McCloud.
I have mixed feelings about anthologies, but usually try to pick them up to gain exposure to artists I'd normally never see...in this case I wish I hadn't seen some of them, or those particular segments of their work.
Maybe other editors do better/more-to-my-taste compilations and presentations,
To be honest I reached 80% I was on a plane with only that loaded on my kindle, I am no long on a plane and can not bear to neglect my better options.
The writing style was poor, the characters thin and unbelievable, and the editing spotty; I should no longer be subjected to spelling errors in print. To be fair, I was expecting a very different book, maybe I will find that in Nickolas Cook's ‘Alice in Zombieland' ...not the White Rabbit Chronicle, or whatever it is with Alice Bell, couldn't finish the sample of it.
Loved the beginning, started to loose me by the end though. Two big pet peeves though: interjecting a two-page spead of pictures in the middle of a word– it really threw off the continuity– and some of the cartoons were really hard to read, which made it frustrating.
Otherwise, good coverage of an interesting subject matter
A little convoluted, but I kept turning the pages, and I was forewarned: it is called “Not Simple”. It was interesting, the beginning was a little over-the-top, and in a few places it felt like it was trying too hard or was a little too cliche, but it has that lure of forbidden mystery and sadness. Really well done though when Ian returns from meeting Kylie's boyfriend and has gum