3.5 Better written than the usual Reacher clone.

A great little novella - interesting universe and characters.

Absolutely excellent - one of the best books I've read this year.

Superb world building, fantastic characters, terrific story line, amazing action. I've run out of superlatives; possibly the best book the author has written.

Bring on part two now

I'm normally a hard SF guy. Becky Chambers is the foremost writer of soft SF. A short, beautiful, novella.
More please.

Great story, well written. Great characters and world building, and a unique plot. Bring on the next installment.

2.5 - the writing style is disjointed and needs a good edit. Some interesting ideas, but the characters are flat. Is this a YA book, maybe.

Bunny McGarry stories are always amusing and good fun.

Dark undercurrents of dread and fear. Escalating violence as Tomas Piety begins to realise what he has actually got himself into, and what he is going to have to do
for he, and his friends and family, to survive.
Bring on the final installment.

Rude, crude, amusing and great fun.

I hadn't realised it was a young adult novel. Not really my sort of book. Someone younger needs to properly rate this book.

A dark, gritty, urban noir fantasy. Lots of magic related violence either inflicted by, or inflicted upon, the hero Eric Carter. Pretty well written, apart from the repeated use of the phrase “ass over teakettle” which really irritated me for some reason. That aside, I enjoyed the book.

That was pretty good fun. Interesting characters and a reasonable plot, with a little humour thrown in for good measure.
Hope that there are books in the series

Just about a three. Badly needs proof reading

Gave up after the first 25%. Painfully written in the present tense, with lots of grammar and punctuation mistakes. Needs serious editing.

A brilliant sequel to A Memory Called Empire