Jon

Predictable and not the best of the star trek books in the stargazer series. I enjoyed this the least. There were some good interactions but too many that felt shallow and meaningless.

Enjoyable but far too predictable.

Interesting but the plot holes and silly decisions are getting more common. The series needed a it more tightening up in the plot to not leave you thinking ‘Why didn't they just do X?' still, it's Picard and he's always great to see in action again.

Not as good as the previous ones in the series but enjoyable still.

These are enjoyable stories but they seem to have too many weak plot holes to be brilliant. I'm enjoying the series though and like all the characters.

Fun read, not brilliant, but worth reading and enjoyable.

A good adventure but a bit formulaic and clich??d. Could have done with more twists, but enjoyable nonetheless.

An interesting and fun read about Picard's first command.

Enjoyable

I got the audiobook as I wanted to listen to Harry tell his version of events himself and Very interesting listen it was too. You can't help but in the end feel sorry for all of them and the goldfish bowl they must live in.

I'm a bit unsure what to rate this book, it's more than a 3 but not a 4 - for me.

I loved most of the book, through the epilogue was interesting and a good twist, but didn't really like the resolution of the main story much. It just didn't seem to fit with the build up. Enjoyed it overall though and worth reading if you like end of world adventures.

Not sure what to make of this. Overly long, a bit confusing at times (though that may be my ageing brain) and possibly even a bit slow and dull. Grand ideas, some really good sections and did make you think.

Interesting story that fits into TOS world well but lacks depth in the writing. I also found it hard at times to see the characters from the enterprise as themselves from their dialog and felt the background world needed more expansion. I have no idea of what a screenplay looks like but it felt more like I'd imagine that to be.

An excellent account of Pedestal and insight into the terror if being a sailor aboard one of the ships, particularly the merchants.

Any book with Bunny McGarry in is going to be good and this one features him as the main hero. Funny, great plot and wonderful characters another great installment in this every expanding series.

For me, this wasn't a patch on all his other books. As usual the main characters - particularly Diller and Smithy were great, Muroe and Wilkins were fun too, but the story was too silly for me to really enjoy as much as his others . I'd read another in the Diller and Smithy series if there is one as perhaps it was just me and this particular story that didn't get along.

Possibly not a 5 star book but certainly more than 4. Fun, good twists and turns, great characters and ridiculous moments.

As usual the characters are great, the relationships fabulous and the plot intricate. It's all hooked to together with some wonderful humour and lines and Dorothy is the Granny we'd all love to have. When's Burns getting her owns series though, or Phil...

Very amusing and short

Great to find out the origins of the Sisters of the Saint, who surely deserve there own series and possibly TV show too.

Not up to the usual Caimh standards but OK.

Great plot and well written, maybe a weaker ending than normal but still a fabulous read. Filling in all the loose ends of the original trilogy etc.

Ridiculously good, funny, great hero in Bunny, feel good book. Buy it.

An interesting and sad autobiography of one of the all time great players who I used to watch at Portman Road many years ago. A giant of the game, but a sad life full of many mistakes. The book is not what you'd call well written, and is also a bit repetive at times, but it sounds honest as Kevin saw it and is a wonderful recollection of his life, though you are left with a feeling of sadness and what if...

A fabulous prequel explains loads of things I'd wondered about in the tilogy. Loved it.